The Best Whiskies for Making an Old Fashioned
As far as classic cocktails go, there’s nothing quite like an Old Fashioned. It’s simple to make, has a distinctive, enjoyable personality, and can appeal to anyone from the hard-bitten bourbon drinker through to the burgeoning mixologist trying to impress some friends.
Best of all, a well-crafted old fashioned whiskey drink is like capturing sweet lightning in a rocks glass. If you can make it right, it’s a cocktail sure to delight.
The following article will outline the simplicity of an old fashioned recipe and the few parts used to make them, before outlining American whiskey – bourbon, wheated bourbon, and rye whiskey – for you to utilize in making this slice of cocktail greatness. Sure, you can use a Scotch or Irish Whiskey, but that’s being too cheeky!
Whether you want to maximize a cheap cocktail option or dazzle onlookers with a premium high rolling whiskey cocktail in a sparkling old fashioned glass, the options below can help you put together an old fashioned cocktail with style and distinction.
What is an old fashioned cocktail and how do you make one?
Whiskey Old Fashioned Recipe
- 1 1/2 oz Kentucky bourbon or rye whiskey
- 1 sugar cube or teaspoon brown sugar
- 2 dashes Angostura bitters or aromatic bitters
- A few dashes of spring water
- Cocktail cherry, lemon twist or orange peel to garnish
The whiskey old fashioned is an old school classic cocktail recipe. An old fashioned is a stirred drink, not shaken, and because of its simplicity it’s usually created in the glass before serving. There’s no need for a cocktail mixer jug or mixing glass and fancy bar shenanigans to make a quality version of this drink.
The traditional old fashioned recipe likes to muddle up the sugar cube or a spoonful of brown sugar with water and a couple dashes of angostura bitters, but simple syrup or orange bitters works fine to sweeten the mix.
You can garnish with a brandied cherry if you want to keep grandma happy, a maraschino cherry (you’ll hear some folks call it a Luxardo cherry), lemon twist, sliver of lemon peel, or even orange peel rabbit ears if you want to show off.
What are the best American whiskies for making an old fashioned?
1. Buffalo Trace Bourbon
Buffalo Trace is an amazing Kentucky straight bourbon from the distiller also responsible for Sazerac American whiskey. It’s a smooth and refined tasting bourbon whiskey that can go into literally any smooth cocktail recipe and work brilliantly
The tasting notes for Buffalo Trace are described as, “a complex aroma of vanilla, mint and molasses. Pleasantly sweet to the taste with notes of brown sugar and spice that give way to oak, toffee, dark fruit and anise. This whiskey finishes long and smooth with serious depth.”
Buffalo Trace is a must add for any whiskey drinker or casual bartender looking for a classic cocktail with subtlety and well rounded flavor.
2. Redemption 10-Year-Old Barrel Proof High Rye Bourbon
The two founders of Redemption were passionate about bringing rye spirit back dominance and their commitment can be clearly felt in this high proof bourbon, where it’s bottled at 114.8 proof.
The 10-Year-Old High Rye Bourbon has a mash bill of 60% Corn, 36% Rye and 4% malted barley that results in a beautiful colored spirit; dark gold with flecks of crimson that shows the balance between sweetness and spice you’ll find in its flavor.
Its hints of toffee, honey and roasted nut give way to the taste of star anise and lemongrass. While bottled at 114.8 proof its smoothness on the palate surprises throughout.
This Redemption expression forms the perfect bedrock to crafting a high quality, premium old fashioned cocktail.
3. Rittenhouse Rye Whiskey
Rittenhouse Rye Whiskey is a favorite for the bonded whiskey drinker. The brand is known for a strong, spicy flavor in their rye whiskey, making it one of the best whiskies for old fashioned.
Taste wise the Rittenhouse rye is well balanced, with caramel and cinnamon flavors helping contrast the bold rye and baking spice taste against hints of fruit such as apple and pear.
Made at the Heaven Hill Distillery in Kentucky – home of Old Fitzgerald and the popular Elijah Craig and Evan Williams straight bourbon brands – it’s distilled in bonded oak for a bigger kick and heavier ABV (50%).
4. High West Double Rye! Barrel Aged Rye Whiskey
For a spirit to call itself American rye whiskey, the mash bill must be made up of at least 51 percent actual rye grain. You’ll find some rye bills filled out with brown sugar, corn, or malted barley, or even finished in wine, rum, or brandy casks to add another flavor dimension.
High West Double Rye! Barrel Aged Rye Whiskey is the blend of a spicy 2-year-old rye whiskey with a smoother, older barrel whiskey.
Double Rye! blends straight ryes aged in oak barrels for two to seven years in new, charred white oak barrels to create a bold up-front taste that mellows to hints of wildflowers and anise on the palate.
The Double Rye! is a quality mid-priced American Rye that drinkers of all types can enjoy whether sipping an Old Fashioned cocktail, in whiskey sour or drinking neat, and topped our list of best rye whiskies to try.
5. Old Forester 86 Proof
Old Forester 86 Proof is America’s first bottled bourbon, and a quality drop at a cheap price. The Old Forester bourbon brand celebrates its 150th birthday in 2020, so it’s a natural bourbon whiskey for use in an old fashioned.
A touch of oak and pine provides a strong underpinning of flavor that works well against the simple syrup or aromatic bitters then leveled off by a touch of waterand lemon juice in the whiskey glass.
The bourbon is quite sharp at first but softens and settles quickly, featuring tasting notes of toasted oak, sweet corn and rye spice grain part of the distinctive Kentucky bourbon flavor.
6. George Dickel Superior No. 12 Tennessee Whisky
Yeah, sure. An old fashioned is supposed to be made from rye or bourbon. But hear me out!
George Dickel Superior No. 12 Tennessee Whisky combines older whiskies selected by Master Distiller John Lunn to create a more assertive flavor while maintaining the smooth brown sugar Tennessee polish.
This is a top quality smooth drinking Tennessee Whisky (Dickel spelled it that way believing it’s as smooth as any scotch) and it comes in 90 proof, the only bottle to have that distinction.
Superior No. 12 offers the tasting note of rich oak and subtle vanilla that leads to a finish hinting at maple syrup, butter, and smoke, which is a treat for your rocks glass or highball.
7. Knob Creek 12 Year Old Bourbon Whiskey
By selecting the finest grains and finishing in white oak barrels with maximum char, Knob Creek has created a top quality 100 proof bourbon filled with rich flavor and sweetness.
The 50% ABV gives the premium American whiskey some extra oomph amidst the smoothness.
All the flavors of oak, caramel and vanilla present within those barrels are concentrated year after year, removing harshness of flavor while still maintaining the unmistakable full-flavor of Kentucky Straight Bourbon.
If you’re looking to create a premium cocktail such as an old fashioned, whisky sour or Mint Julep, this is a quality choice of bourbon.
Top 29 Best Watches Under $500 For Men
With cellphones so ubiquitous, your watch choice can be less about telling time and more about personal style. However, a watch is not ‘just’ a watch. For example, the vast majority are made for right-handed people, but a select few cater to the lefties among us. There is a wide range in functionality and size.
The wristwatch is also one of the few socially acceptable accessories for men, so why not have a small selection? If you’re not cashing a CEO’s paycheck just yet, here are the top 28 most handsome watches for men that retail for under $500.
Got a bigger budget? Then check out our guide to the best men’s watches under $1000 instead.
Top 29 Best Watches Under $500 For Men
1. Tommy Hilfiger Stainless Steel Men’s Watch
If you like the feel of a pliable, non-metal band but aren’t comfortable with genuine leather, this watch comes equipped with a handsome synthetic band. At 46mm in diameter, this watch is perfect for men of smaller stature, as it will not overpower your hand or make it look like you’re wearing your father’s watch. With bold Arabic numerals, a stainless steel case, and classic styling, this watch is an outstanding choice for an everyday watch and the man on a budget.
2. Nordgreen Pioneer – Black Dial
Check Price
Get 15% off using the discount code NEXTL at checkout
Not everyone has an endless amount of cash to drop on a luxury timepiece. If you’re money-conscious but want something high-end, then why not consider the Nordgreen Pioneer.
An inspired take on a classic Chronograph, Nordgreen celebrates the Danish with what they call a timepiece “that captures the sustainable future.” Available in various dial colors from blue, black, and white. There’s even the choice of three case colors – gunmetal, silver, and rose gold. A perfect addition to the collection of any watch enthusiast.
3. Fossil Grant Brown Leather Watch
This lovely offering by Fossil features slim Roman numeral hour markers and delicate cut-out hands. The casing is stainless steel and is water-resistant to 165 feet, making it a great dive watch. The band is made of supple, soft calfskin leather and uses a buckle closure.
Of course, this timepiece also comes with the generous 11-year warranty and it’s own fun tin. This watch oozes class and is great for nearly every occasion in your life.
4. Citizen Sport Stainless Steel Men’s Watch With Brown Leather Band
If you don’t want to deal with changing out a battery in a digital watch, this watch is powered by either natural or indoor lighting. The mineral crystal face and stainless steel case make this watch water-resistant to 330 feet, making it a great choice for swimmers and snorkelers.
Handsome and utilitarian, this is a great watch for everyday wear. It’s one of the best watches for men who are always on the go.
5. Fossil Men’s Machine Chronograph Silicone Watch
This watch was designed with the active man in mind. The knurled silicone band stands up to sweat and oils without issue, and the timepiece itself is water-resistant to 165 feet.
The patterned bezel and quality craftsmanship of the black dial is excellent, as is to be expected from a Fossil watch. It even comes in the iconic and collectible tin!
6. Citizen Men’s Eco-Drive Watch
This men’s watch features Japanese quartz movement that charges itself indoors or out when exposed to light, making it a great choice for those who don’t want to change out the battery too often. The stitched canvas strap is soft against your skin and will wick away moisture, while the mineral crystal face stands up to the rigors of your everyday life.
Water-resistant to 330 feet, this dive watch is a classic and simple design you’ll be proud of for years to come.
7. Invicta Pro Diver Chronograph Men’s Watch
Another gorgeous offering by Invicta, this watch features a bold design with a slightly nautical feel to it. It will look at home whether you’re wearing a business suit or are going for a dive of less than 660 feet. This piece is also covered by a one-year warranty as a matter of course. The luminosity feature and magnified date window make it a great choice if you work or play in low light.
If you want something that looks like a Tag Heuer but without the luxury watch brand price tag, this is a good option!
8. Casio Edifice Multi-Function Men’s Watch
This watch has three sub-dials for 12 hour, 60 minute and 60-second displays, in addition to the standard time. It also features a fold-over, push-down clasp on the stainless strap, keeping it secure throughout your activities. If you’re looking for a classy timepiece that shrieks sophistication, this is a great choice.
9. Fossil Machine Three Hand Stainless Steel Men’s Watch
This quality watch is a chameleon piece. It looks at home as a dress watch riding below the cuff of your best suit, and it also looks great paired with jeans and a t-shirt. Backed by Fossil’s 11-year warranty as a matter of course and beautifully crafted, this smoke-colored piece is guaranteed to become the go-to accessory for nearly every occasion.
10. MVMT Watches Black Face Men’s Watch
If you like the look of a simple watch, this minimalist offering from MVMT is right up your alley. With just a plain black face, tick marks to denote the hours and a single date window, there is nothing overdone or extravagant about this design. The is understated and suited to the simple design. It’s definitely a classy, low-key piece for the budget-conscious.
11. Timex Weekender Watch
If you’re looking for a fun watch to pair with casual outfits, this is a great option. The band is blue and yellow woven nylon, and the face features both civilian and military timekeeping. An Indiglo night light is also included. This watch is water-resistant to 99 feet, meaning it can withstand splashes of water or exposure to rain but you won’t want to submerge it.
12. PUMA Ultrasize Black Sport Men’s Watch
Boasting a 50mm diameter, this piece is perfect for the large-framed man or one who likes to wear his accessories oversized. A true fashion statement, this sports watch comes in eight different colors schemes to match your favorite hues.
Do be aware, however, that the dial knob is configure for left-handed men!
13. Timex Easy Reader Men’s Watch
Another dress watch designed with the older gentleman in mind, this watch features a white dial with generously sized numerals that do not appear comical to the casual observer.
It’s also an excellent choice if you take your contacts out at night and still want to be able to check the time. With classic lines and a simple white face, the watch would not be out of place at any casual gathering. It comes with Timex’s one-year warranty at no additional charge.
14. Fossil Nate Men’s Chronograph Watch
For men who like a more gritty, industrial feel to their accessories, this Fossil watch is right on point. The bezel is gear-edged and the face is utilitarian black and gray. Water-resistant to 165 feet, this watch is a great choice if you like your adornments to be understated yet add visual interest.
It’s definitely a stand-out piece, for those who would take notice!
15. Timex Expedition Field Chronograph Men’s Watch
Featuring an indigo night light, tachymeter, a date window and a buckle closure, this watch is perfect for men who like to work or play outdoors. It is also water-resistant to 330 feet, making it a great choice for snorkeling or swimming.
You won’t want to wear it for diving, however. With classic, black styling and a genuine crystal face, this is a timepiece that will stand the test of time in both form and function.
16. Seiko 5 Automatic Stainless Steel Men’s Watch
This Seiko automatic watch has all the bells and whistles you need, but presents it all in a plain and strikingly attractive manner. It features a date window in either English or Spanish, sword-shaped hands, a sweeping second hand and a mineral dial window. This is a great option for the man on the go. The canvas strap can be removed and hand-washed if sweat or other odors become an issue.
This watch is not water-resistant, so you’ll only want to wear it when you won’t be popping by the pool for a swim!
17. Invicta Pro Diver Collection Silver-Tone Men’s Watch
For those who prefer an all-metal timepiece, the stainless steel Invicta fits the bill nicely. It has a similar aesthetic to a Tag Heuer watch, but at a more affordable price. Equipped with a unilateral bezel and removable links, the band can be customized to fit your wrist perfectly. The face is flame fusion crystal and features a magnifier to highlight the date window.
It’s also water-resistant to 660 feet. If you’re looking for a gorgeous watch that stands up to an active lifestyle, this is an excellent choice.
18. Seiko Men’s Adventure-Solar Classic Casual Watch
This Seiko watch derives its power from either natural or indoor light and can withstand water depths of up to 330 feet. The supple brown leather strap and timeless brushed steel give this piece an attractive look, and the alarm chronograph is easy to set.
If you’re looking for a watch that can serve as a backup for your wake-up call while traveling, stand up to the elements and look awesome, this casual wrist watch is a winner.
19. Nautica Men’s Stainless Steel Watch with Blue Resin Band
Featuring a plethora of options and a smart, snappy style, this a great casual watch with a eye-catching blue dial. The hardy resin band is adjustable, and the face is protected by a mineral window. Whether for work or play, this bold blue design is handsome and substantial on the wrist. It comes with Nautica’s five-year warranty at no additional charge.
20. Citizen Sport Men’s Stainless Steel Watch with Black Leather Band
The black, red and white face of this piece eschews the traditional two-tone color scheme so often employed in other watches, and the contrasting stitching on the band adds creative flair. It comes backed by Citizen’s five-year warranty and will compliment any casual outfit.
21. Alessi Tic15 Analog Display Analog Quartz Black Men’s Watch
Another not-quite-round offering on our list, the curved square casing of this piece gives it instant visual appeal. Sleek and clean, this unfussy design will be a compliment to almost any occasion. It has quartz movement and is water-resistant to 99 feet, making it a great choice for everyday wear.
22. Invicta 1517 I Force Collection Watch
Another on our list designed for left-handed men, this watch is something special. Water-resistant to 330 feet and featuring oversize stenciled numbers and a sub dial, this watch is great for any casual outfit. The cloth band is extremely durable and stands up to dirt, sweat and grime.
If you lead an active lifestyle, this watch will be right at home in your collection.
23. TRIWA Blue Steel Nevil Canvas Watch
This watch comes in a whopping 14 color variations, all of them beautiful. You may decide to add more than one to your collection!
Designed in Sweden, this watch features Japanese quartz movement, a stainless steel casing and a strap made from Tärnsjö organic leather. TRIWA, which stands for Transforming the Industry of Watches, believes in the artistry of fine jewelry and it shows in their product.
24. Victorinox Swiss Army Alliance Watch
Another fine dress watch from the makers of the Swiss Army knife, this watch is emblazoned with the internally recognized cross and shield emblem. It has no sub-dials, tachymeter or other add-ons to detract from its simple and appealing style.
This watch will be at home with all but the most formal of outfits and carries a two-year warranty.
25. Ingersoll Automatic Stainless Steel Bull Run Watch
Again, Ingersoll remakes the classics and brings them into the present day. With a highly polished stainless steel casing, two sub-dials, a date aperture and arrow-shaped hands, this quartz watch is beautiful.
The band features contrasting stitching on the fine-grain leather, adding depth and detail to the workmanship. This watch will compliment any casual occasion and can be relied upon for years to come.
26. Tissot Quickster Chronograph Black Leather Men’s Watch
Made with scratch-resistant sapphire crystal and Swiss automatic movement, this watch is a smart and utilitarian choice. If you’re looking for a solid Swiss watch that isn’t flashy, this is an excellent option. It’s also guaranteed for two years.
27. Seiko Sport Solar Men’s Beige Watch
Are you getting tired of squinting down at your watch or holding it closer and closer to your face? Don’t worry, we all get a bit nearsighted with age, especially over the age of 40.
If you’re not quite ready for reading glasses or a comically huge watch, this is a great choice from Seiko. The numerals, indices and luminous hands stand out in stark white against a black background, and the numerals are generous in size. It’s a perfect casual watch for the older gentleman.
28. Seiko Men’s 5 Watch Blue Canvas Band
This simple and affordable watch has a clean, crisp aesthetic to it and doesn’t bog down its design with a ton of bells and whistles. It’s time and date, end of.
If you want a watch for casual wear, this Seiko is a shoo-in. The band is forgiving and comfortable against your wrist, and it’s blue color will likely compliment your existing wardrobe. The price is also extremely affordable.
29. Tommy Hilfiger Men’s Stainless Steel Watch With Brown Leather Band
Featuring the Hilfiger logo at the three o’clock position, this wrist watch is a statement piece. It is a bright, shiny stainless steel work of art that you’ll be proud to wear at all but the most stuffy of workplaces. The calfskin leather band uses a buckle closure and the date window is beside the logo at three o’clock.
If you’re a fan of Tommy clothing, cologne or luggage, you can complete your look with this stunning accessory.
